jacqueline berenson twitter
In one example, he cites a recent, massive review of the evidence on marijuana’s benefits and harms from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, claiming the report, on the link between marijuana and psychosis, “declared the issue settled.”. It concluded that “marijuana use does not induce violent crime, and the links between marijuana use and property crime are thin.”. It’s a fraction of a fraction of a percent of all violent crime in America. The result is the book in which that conversation is now being retold — a book that’s gotten widespread favorable coverage in CNBC, the New Yorker, Mother Jones, and the Marshall Project, and landed op-eds from Berenson about his findings in the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, and the Philadelphia Inquirer.
But the report ultimately concluded that the evidence in this area was merely “limited” to “moderate,” so more research is necessary. He left the Times in 2010 to devote himself to writing fiction. She is a forensic psychologist. Berenson brings up case after case of a brutal crime, then argues that the attacker had a history of marijuana use or used cannabis shortly before the attack. Tell Your Children claims to inform its readers of the “truth” about marijuana, but it instead repeatedly misleads them. To make his case, Berenson early on reaches back to the initial wave of reefer madness, looking at the reception of marijuana in the late 19th and early 20th centuries in Mexico and India. The United States is in the middle of one of the most consequential presidential elections of our lifetimes.
Age Facts, Is A1saud a Boy or Girl? Beyond the harms on individuals, overuse and addiction are probably bad for society too.
An increase of 0.4 percent in psychosis would mean an extra 160,000 of those kids will suffer debilitating mental illness by 2040 or so. On the other side, Berenson does make some good points about the overstated benefits of medical marijuana.
They linked violent crimes — often involving immigrant perpetrators — to previous marijuana use. Even though Berenson is making an explosive claim (one that media reports and police did not make when the case was in the news, as far as I can tell), that’s all he gives us to support his suggestion that marijuana caused the attack. There isn’t a serious attempt to weed out confounding variables, with only a vague mention of some sort of “statistical analysis.” The correlation between marijuana legalization and the increase in violent crimes is given — and repeated throughout the book, as well as Berenson’s op-eds — as if the truth is obvious.
Then again, maybe the lack of evidence that legalization had a big effect on violent crime shouldn’t be very surprising — based on Berenson’s admission early on in the book, where he gives some numbers for what he expects the effects of marijuana to be on psychosis and violence. And it really was widely believed at the time that marijuana caused insanity and violence, which may have created a self-fulfilling prophecy since such behavior was essentially deemed as typical while stoned. Berenson leverages these anecdotes and limited data to argue that heavy marijuana use, spurred by the legalization of pot in several US states, is already leading to a “black tide of psychosis” and “red tide of violence.” He warns that things will only get worse as the legal pot industry grows bigger, with an incentive to stifle heavy regulations on cannabis. This doesn’t rule out Berenson’s claims. He cites various studies that he suggests add scientific weight to his claims.
The black market for marijuana also effectively funds violent drug cartels and trafficking organizations around the world, allowing them to carry out their violence. We’ve seen this before. “Yet they did.”. At the very least, it’s a much more complicated story than Berenson’s one-sided portrayal. As the National Academies’ report makes clear, there is still a lot about cannabis that we just don’t know, including its harms and benefits. The man tied the knot with Jacqueline Berenson.
The book, Tell Your Children, has received a lot of media attention, but it’s essentially Reefer Madness 2.0. A 2018 study published in Nature Neuroscience, for example, suggested that it’s more likely that schizophrenia leads to marijuana use (potentially to cope or self-medicate), not the other way around. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Campos cautioned that he’s only read two photocopied pages from Berenson’s book in which he’s cited. Chat with creators. Because, unfortunately, there are plenty,” he concludes. Murders rose about 20 percent nationally from 2013 to 2017, and aggravated assaults about 10 percent. About 40 million Americans were born in the last decade. They could create systems that make it harder for users to consume too much. If you haven’t, please consider helping everyone understand this presidential election: Contribute today from as little as $3. The man initially worked as a business reporter in Denver Post. He has siblings as well. But Berenson dismisses this evidence, going on to focus on reports, including the faulty asylum cases, that back up his point.
He writes, “In 1901, for example, a newspaper reported on a man who attacked strangers on a street and then ‘turned on himself and with bites he tore apart his own arms until a straitjacket could be put on him … he was crazy under the influence of marihuana.’”, Mexicans “had no cultural reason to view marijuana negatively,” he later adds.
#1 NEW YORK TIMES BEST SELLER. When it comes to marijuana and violence, you can pull out correlations in the opposite direction, too. Trans, Gender, Girlfriend Julia Raleigh Tik Tok, Helen Stanley Goblin Works Garage Age: Husband, Wiki, Married, Bio Facts. For that, I recommend Marijuana Legalization: What Everyone Needs to Know by Caulkins, Kleiman, and Beau Kilmer, all of whom are actual drug policy researchers and scholars. In likely the most provocative claim in Tell Your Children, Berenson tries to argue that pot is already causing a spike in violence. Moreover, he left The New York Times in 2010 to write novels. Many thousands of those will wind up committing murder and other violent crime.”.
In 2017, the state had 230 murders and 13,700 aggravated assaults—an increase of about 44 percent for murders and 17 percent for aggravated assaults. But our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism takes resources. Over that period, national homicide rates have fallen more than 50%.”. As with the marijuana-psychosis link, the messiness of correlation and causation is why more rigorous scientific evaluations are needed.
(“No one seemed to connect [West’s] diagnosis to his cannabis use,” Berenson laments.). But is marijuana to blame, the circumstances of its use, or a mix of these and other factors? It’s worth noting you could easily do this kind of thing in the opposite direction — looking up a bunch of studies via Google that show marijuana does not cause psychosis or related disorders. These are users self-reporting in national surveys that they struggle to stop using marijuana even as it leads them to neglect their responsibilities and has other negative impacts on their lives. That’s … it. Berenson did his high schooling from the local school in New Jersey. Hundreds of thousands of people are arrested for marijuana each year in the US — potentially leading to a criminal record or jail time.
That’s worth taking seriously. There’s no consideration about how, for example, the circumstances surrounding someone’s pot use could play a role, as likely occurred with the Mexico cases.
“Based on his data and later findings, Andréasson says he believes that cannabis is responsible for between 10 percent and 15 percent of schizophrenia cases,” Berenson writes. Millions rely on Vox’s explainers to understand an increasingly chaotic world. “Do you want more cases? Expect more arrests soon as further improvements are made. The book largely focuses on grisly anecdotes of violent crimes committed under the influence of marijuana, the kind of “reefer madness” stories authorities and the media leaned on when they first prohibited cannabis in the 20th century. Observations and anecdotes, not rigorous scientific analysis, are at the core of the book’s claim that legal marijuana will cause — and, in fact, is causing — a huge rise in psychosis and violence in America. His age is 47 years. As of now, he has launched various books that became the bestsellers. They could restrict marketing.
We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. These reports culminated in Reefer Madness, the 1936 movie, and the Marihuana Tax Act of 1937, which was effectively the first federal prohibition of marijuana. The National Academies’ analysis found “conclusive or substantial evidence” that cannabis can help with chronic pain, chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting, and patient-reported multiple sclerosis spasticity symptoms, but the use of marijuana for other conditions has limited to no scientific evidence. They could limit the strength of doses. The National Academies’ review of the evidence speaks to this.
Sign up for the Future Perfect newsletter. Much of Berenson’s book focuses on the history of schizophrenia, psychosis, and the marijuana legalization movement. Even when the economy and the news advertising market recovers, your support will be a critical part of sustaining our resource-intensive work.
But Berenson’s book, with its sensationalist claims and shoddy analysis of the evidence, doesn’t genuinely address those concerns. In the late 19th century and early 20th centuries, as marijuana was introduced to new parts of the US, the media and government officials published a lot of reports exaggerating the risks of cannabis. Berenson is a married man with children. He writes that “in the late 1970s, once enough people experienced marijuana’s impacts up close, the tide shifted almost instantly.”, He also worries, though, that it may be too late — that legalization is already creating a huge industry with a big financial incentive to exaggerate the benefits of marijuana, downplay the risks, and fight off regulations. Berenson suggests that the attack was caused by marijuana, citing a previous social media post in which the attacker discussed cannabis use. His conclusion: “While it is true that homicide rates went up in CO and WA more than they rose for the nation as a whole, the homicide rates in Colorado and Washington were actually below what the data predicted they would have been given the trends in homicides from 2000-2012,” which is almost entirely before they legalized marijuana. There is also a lot we don’t know about marijuana, including whether the far more potent strains of cannabis that people are using today will present new problems that weren’t seen before. There’s also the risk of addiction. About The Author.
He cites only the parts of the report that are favorable to his thesis — a disservice to the massive, rigorous work of the 16-person committee of scientists, who pored over thousands of studies for the review. I know Campos personally.